Best Pizza in Town

Neapolitan pizza, hand-stretched in the Wheeler District

Order online

Featured

View menu

Scratch dough, airy crust

Fresh "00" flour dough, fermented 24 hours and hand-stretched to order — that airy crust is the whole point.

See the menu

Because what's better than pizza? Pizza AND Gelato.

House-made in small batches every day. From the classic Stracciatella to our own creations like Nana Pudding, there’s a scoop for everyone. Grab one after your pizza—or just come for the gelato. We won’t judge.

Bring the pizzeria to you

Are you looking to have pizza at your special occasion? We cater for corporate events, birthday parties, and everything in between.

Learn about catering

Straight from the shop

Small-batch gelato and scratch-made pizza, fresh every day. Here's a taste of what we're about.

We have been coming here since they opened last year, and it’s our #1 pizza spot in OKC. Our family is well versed in italian pizza/food and this is top notch. Better yet, it’s family owned and local. The owners are always there running it, and even make their gelato from scratch. We have so enjoyed

Taylor

Delicious pizza! I ordered via a food delivery app a Margherita, a Marinara and The Veggie white pizza. All of them were prepared the neapolitan style and very tasty. The ingredients were fresh and the crust had a good consistency. I just missed more of the cheese on the Margherita pizza. The proce

Thomas D.

I had a fantastic experience at this pizza restaurant! The crust was perfectly cooked—crispy on the outside and soft inside, just the way it should be. The sauce was full of flavor, adding the perfect balance to every bite. The restaurant itself was spotless, and the staff were fast and friendly, ma

Michelle R.

Loved the vibe of this place! Owners are super nice, and very educational on what’s in their food. Gelato is fantastic and they have so many flavors to choose from. So many types of pizza with the option for Gluten Free Crust. We will definitely be back!! Who knew a quick google search would lead us

Samantha H.

More than pizza, we're family

American Gothic Pizza is a family-run kitchen built on hospitality. We know our regulars by name, we hire and support our neighbors, and we treat everyone who walks up like they belong at our table.

Two locations, one obsession with great pizza

OKC — Wheeler District
Brick & mortar
Our home base. Hand-stretched pies, house-made gelato, and craft cocktails at 1715 Wheeler St, Oklahoma City, OK.
Frisco — Food Truck
Thursday–Sunday
Catch us firing pies to order at Rollertown Beerworks, 6450 Main St, Frisco, TX.